On Mar 24, 2017, at 3:57 AM, Alex Hankey wrote:
Jack, No mechanism of reduction of wave packets has any hope
per se of yielding an understanding of the taste of blue cheese,
or the quality of perception of the colours saffron, emerald or indigo.
I disagree. Any physics of consciousness including Stapp's, Penrose, mine that explains qualia explains all those distinctions as different patterns of the entanglement of qubits in the macro-quantum coherent pilot wave that image the different electromagnetic beable patterns whose reactions cause them.
The articles here measure the classical beable dynamics (independent of Planck's constant h) in the Sutherland PQM Lagrangian whose reactions on their Frohlich coherent advanced destiny and retarded history qubit pilot fields induce the qualia in our streams of consciousness.
Our imaginings of things future are dancing impressions in our destiny fields. Our memories are dancing impressions in our history fields (remembrances of things past)
Reading Thoughts with Brain Imaging - MIT Technology Review
https://www.technologyreview.com/s/412084/reading-thoughts-with-brain-imaging/
Feb 18, 2009 - Functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) looks more and more like a window into the mind. In a study published online today in Nature, ...
Scientists use brain imaging to reveal the movies in our mind ...
news.berkeley.edu/2011/09/22/brain-movies/
Sep 22, 2011 - BERKELEY -- Imagine tapping into the mind of a coma patient, ... Mind-readingthrough brain imaging technology is a common sci-fi theme.
Scientists Can't Read Your Mind With Brain Scans (Yet) | WIRED
https://www.wired.com/2014/04/brain-scan-mind-reading/
Apr 29, 2014 - Scientists Can't Read Your Mind With Brain Scans (Yet) ... to reconstruct pictures of faces that the subjects had been looking at during the scan.
Brain decoding: Reading minds : Nature News & Comment
www.nature.com/news/brain-decoding-reading-minds-1.13989
Oct 23, 2013 - On the left-hand side of the screen is a reel of film clips that Gallant showed to a study participant during a brain scan. And on the right side of ...
Scan a brain, read a mind? - CNN.com
www.cnn.com/2014/04/12/health/brain-mind-reading/
Apr 12, 2014 - Scientists have made significant strides in being able to decode thoughts based on brain activity.
You are simply stuck in primitive thinking.
Indeed, your mode of thinking, your metaphysical brain-washing is the same as Deepak's and many others.
You are like the pre-Copernican Scholastics who thought that Earth was the center of the universe.
You have elevated qualia Q to an ineffable supernatural phenomenon.
BTW PQM does not have reduction in the same sense that Penrose does - but that is a technical difference - the basic ideas are similar only the means are different. The basic idea is that qualia are excitations in the quantum bit mental field directly induced by classical electromagnetic sensory input signals. Penrose invokes tiny changes in the curvature of spacetime for the same tiny mass in a quantum superposition, my adaptation of Sutherland's PQM math relies simply on his new action-reaction Lagrangian prior to taking the PQM --> QM limit.
PQM = Q/ = very complex entanglement pattern of a large number of qubits
PS note that in Bohm picture Penrose's mass m is not in two places at once at all - it is only in one place, but the empty branch of the quantum potential overlaps with the occupied branch and that overlap has the mirage of spooky action-a-distance. See Bohm and Hiley "Undivided Universe" for details on how this works. There is never any literal collapse - empty branches of Q continue to exist and they can be re-awakened (resurrected) i.e. "quantum erasure" in principle if not in practice if the entanglement is to a huge number of environmental systems (environmental decoherence).
Nor the feelings conveyed by the Brandenberg Concertos,
or a good joke. And where do bliss and pain fit in all that.
The endorphin system does not explain what it feels like when
you use a good natural form of stimulation like creative activity.
How can the reduction of wave packets cover such wide possibilities,
and I am not even half way through the whole list!
Do please think about this. It is a problem that is worth a couple of
decades of thought to solve. At the moment most of us don't even
begin to know where to look, though my opinion is that Omega
Structures in Grottendieck's Topos theory may provide a good
starting point.
Does anyone have any thoughts on that one. Or any expertise to share?
All best wishes to everyone,
as ever,
Alex
On 24 March 2017 at 04:15, JACK SARFATTI wrote:
In order for Orch OR to explain qualia Penrose tacitly assumes that the change in the wave function is the quale. This is very similar to PQM.
In Penrose's theory it is the back-reaction of the classical gravity field beable on the electron beables inside the protein dimers etc. that in turn causes a change in the wave function of those electrons et-al that is the quale. Therefore, the wave function is an intrinsic mental field in order for Penrose's scheme to make any sense at all. Same for Henry Stapp's and Wigner's consciousness as collapse - the thing that collapses must be intrinsically thought like.
On Mar 23, 2017, at 5:09 PM, wrote:
It offers a physical mechanism for the von Neumann reduction of the QM wave function by conscious observation.
Presumably any such mechanism, if artificially constructed, would have similar effects.
On 3/23/2017 4:37 PM, Robert Addinall wrote:
Ok, so Hameroff and Penrose's theory is sort of in the middle - proto consciousness is everywhere, but treats the local consciousness of an individual person or animal as happening actively in the brain.
Still, most of these theories differ from "materialist" theories that seek to explain consciousness in the brain from electrical impulses and related well documented phenomena alone.