Information and Imagination: How Can Mindless Mathematical Laws Give Rise to Aims and Intentions by William B Goodwin

Hello Dr. William Goodwin!

You are right to say that the knowledge of the world primary importance is the imagination

You said perfectly: "This paper suggests that they did received additional ideas and inspiration from the information dimension, and that the existence of the information dimension has accelerated man's development, as well as benefited much of the animal kingdom".

However, you separated the information from it's the carrier - matter. Assuming approval of Descartes's identity of space and matter, that the existence of the information dimension is space.

From New Cartesian Physic great potential in understanding the world. To show this potential in his essay I gave materialistic explanations of the paranormal and supernatural. Visit my essay and you will find something in it about New Cartesian Physic. Note my statement that our brain creates an image of the outside world no inside, and in external space. Hope you rate my essay as high as I am yours. I am waiting your post.

Sincerely, Boris Dizhechko

Thanks William, for the comments and support my essay. Dizhechko Boris

Dear Dr. William B Goodwin,

Please excuse me for I have no intention of disparaging in any way any part of your essay.

I merely wish to point out that "Everything should be made as simple as possible, but not simpler." Albert Einstein (1879 - 1955) Physicist & Nobel Laureate.

Only nature could produce a reality so simple, a single cell amoeba could deal with it.

The real Universe must consist only of one unified visible infinite physical surface occurring in one infinite dimension, that am always illuminated by infinite non-surface light.

A more detailed explanation of natural reality can be found in my essay, SCORE ONE FOR SIMPLICITY. I do hope that you will read my essay and perhaps comment on its merit.

Joe Fisher, Realist

Nice essay Goodwin,

Your ideas and thinking are excellent like,

1. An unmarried caveman sees an attractive woman and he wants her. His aim is clear. By his past experiences, he has learned three choices:

A. He grabs her and gets punched in the face by the guy next to her. He retreats.

B. He grabs her and gets punched in the face by the guy next to her. He battles back and wins.

C. He searches for another woman.

2. Imagination can create new options, new outcomes, and imagined probabilities of success, or failure. Some of those options may not be possible in the physical world, yet they may be enjoyable to imagine. The caveman may imagine that he has magical powers.

3. For example, a musician may have a few notes of a melody in his mind. During his sleep he discovers other notes that produce a rudimentary tune. While sleeping, his brain may have communicated with the information dimension, where some relationship had formed between his initial notes and musical notes associated with different persons in different time periods.

4. Given a willingness to explore, intelligent minds can ask leading questions, can theorize possibilities and can devise additional experiments in an effort to learn more about the information dimension. Maybe they can even answer the question: is it mathematical?

Good EXAMPLES sir, I fully agree with you............

..................... At this point I want you to ask you to please have a look at my essay, where ...............reproduction of Galaxies in the Universe is described. Dynamic Universe Model is another mathematical model for Universe. Its mathematics show that the movement of masses will be having a purpose or goal, Different Galaxies will be born and die (quench) etc...just have a look at my essay... "Distances, Locations, Ages and Reproduction of Galaxies in our Dynamic Universe" where UGF (Universal Gravitational force) acting on each and every mass, will create a direction and purpose of movement.....

I think intension is inherited from Universe itself to all Biological systems

For your information Dynamic Universe model is totally based on experimental results. Here in Dynamic Universe Model Space is Space and time is time in cosmology level or in any level. In the classical general relativity, space and time are convertible in to each other.

Many papers and books on Dynamic Universe Model were published by the author on unsolved problems of present day Physics, for example 'Absolute Rest frame of reference is not necessary' (1994) , 'Multiple bending of light ray can create many images for one Galaxy: in our dynamic universe', About "SITA" simulations, 'Missing mass in Galaxy is NOT required', "New mathematics tensors without Differential and Integral equations", "Information, Reality and Relics of Cosmic Microwave Background", "Dynamic Universe Model explains the Discrepancies of Very-Long-Baseline Interferometry Observations.", in 2015 'Explaining Formation of Astronomical Jets Using Dynamic Universe Model, 'Explaining Pioneer anomaly', 'Explaining Near luminal velocities in Astronomical jets', 'Observation of super luminal neutrinos', 'Process of quenching in Galaxies due to formation of hole at the center of Galaxy, as its central densemass dries up', "Dynamic Universe Model Predicts the Trajectory of New Horizons Satellite Going to Pluto" etc., are some more papers from the Dynamic Universe model. Four Books also were published. Book1 shows Dynamic Universe Model is singularity free and body to collision free, Book 2, and Book 3 are explanation of equations of Dynamic Universe model. Book 4 deals about prediction and finding of Blue shifted Galaxies in the universe.

With axioms like... No Isotropy; No Homogeneity; No Space-time continuum; Non-uniform density of matter(Universe is lumpy); No singularities; No collisions between bodies; No Blackholes; No warm holes; No Bigbang; No repulsion between distant Galaxies; Non-empty Universe; No imaginary or negative time axis; No imaginary X, Y, Z axes; No differential and Integral Equations mathematically; No General Relativity and Model does not reduce to General Relativity on any condition; No Creation of matter like Bigbang or steady-state models; No many mini Bigbangs; No Missing Mass; No Dark matter; No Dark energy; No Bigbang generated CMB detected; No Multi-verses etc.

Many predictions of Dynamic Universe Model came true, like Blue shifted Galaxies and no dark matter. Dynamic Universe Model gave many results otherwise difficult to explain

Have a look at my essay on Dynamic Universe Model and its blog also where all my books and papers are available for free downloading...

http://vaksdynamicuniversemodel.blogspot.in/

Best wishes to your essay.

For your blessings please................

=snp. gupta

Dear William B Goodwin,

You present a very interesting theory that is different from the mainstream theory of the universe. I like original ideas. You conclude: "Here probably the 'a-biological world' learned from the Universe and subsequently the physical systems learnt to pursue the goal of reproduction and formed the "Biological world". Slowly these biological life forms acquired intelligence and now trying to understand Universe! That way probably the goal-oriented behavior is a physical or cosmological trend of the Universe......."

..............Reply...................

Yes Thank you for your liking my essay and nice encouraging comments

Thank you for visiting here

............... Your words..........

.........................

While you have already replied to other commentators on the brief connection between the content of your essay and the question of intent for this essay, I too would have liked to hear more on the connection between the two. I know that the page limit makes it difficult to explain the Dynamic Universe Model and to explain the connection to aims and intent, but in the future revision of this essay I wish that you would give more depth to the connection.

..............Reply...................

I am reproducing the parts of the essay below for you to comprehend easily ......

.... Intent.....

'..... 1.1 About Dynamic Universe Model: In our Dynamic Universe every mass is moving in a direction and goal determined universal gravitational force (UGF) as the indomitable resultant vector of gravitational forces acted by all the other bodies in the Universe. This UGF is not constant force acting in only one direction. This resultant UGF vector force is varying according to ever varying dynamic movements and positions of all the masses in the Universe from time to time. In Dynamic Universe Model, this UGF is the fundamental concept; this model calculates this force "UGF" from moment to moment using its mathematical laws on each and every mass in the SITA simulations. In this way many present-day unsolved physics problems were solved. This method is different from conventional two body problem solution.[10]......'

This UGF sets the goals for every Galaxy or for every mass..

...... Reproduction......

Galaxies take birth in different times and quench (die) in different times in different directions. But the positioning of Galaxies is not random, they will come to a stable 'Dynamic Equilibrium' positions due to UGF is the main theam.

Probably you may have a look at the points given by FQXi as guidelines...

This essay is related to COSMOLOGY, This essay is, Original and is entirely different from all the previously published papers by author, It is unpublished. It is Technically correct. This essay covers the long-term, large-scale goals. This essay addresses questions such as:.............

* How did physical systems that pursue the goal of reproduction arise from an a-biological world?

Relevance:.. Universe is having Galaxies, which take birth and death is happening. In the Cosmos the biological world is also a part in which is reproduction is taking place. The same thing is happening in the Galaxies. In this essay this reproduction ability is emphasized.

* What general features -- like information processing, computation, learning, complexity thresholds, and/or departures from equilibrium -- allow (or proscribe) agency?

Relevance:.. Computer simulations were shown to support the paper.

* How are goals (versus accomplishments) linked to "arrows of time"?

Relevance:.. Here Goals were created by the Mathematics of Dynamic Universe Model in the form of Universal Gravitational Force (UGF). This UGF is the total resultant force on any mass ( here in this case the individual Galaxy) which decides the path to be followed in the next instance. That is how the time is pulling every Galaxy..

* What separates systems that are intelligent from those that are not? Can we measure this separation objectively and without requiring reference to humans?

Not Addressed...

* What is the relationship between causality - the explanation of events in terms of causes - and teleology - the explanation of events in terms of purposes?

Not Addressed...

* Is goal-oriented behavior a physical or cosmic trend, an accident or an imperative?

Relevance:.. Here the goal-oriented behavior is a physical or cosmic trend.

Many papers and books were published by the author on unsolved problems of present day Physics, for example 'Absolute Rest frame of reference is not necessary' (1994) , 'Multiple bending of light ray can create many images for one Galaxy: in our dynamic universe', About "SITA" simulations, 'Missing mass in Galaxy is NOT required', "New mathematics tensors without Differential and Integral equations", "Information, Reality and Relics of Cosmic Microwave Background", "Dynamic Universe Model explains the Discrepancies of Very-Long-Baseline Interferometry Observations.", in 2015 'Explaining Formation of Astronomical Jets Using Dynamic Universe Model, 'Explaining Pioneer anomaly', 'Explaining Near luminal velocities in Astronomical jets', 'Observation of super luminal neutrinos', 'Process of quenching in Galaxies due to formation of hole at the center of Galaxy, as its central densemass dries up', "Dynamic Universe Model Predicts the Trajectory of New Horizons Satellite Going to Pluto" etc., are some more papers from the Dynamic Universe model. Four Books also were published. Book1 shows Dynamic Universe Model is singularity free and body to collision free, Book 2, and Book 3 are explanation of equations of Dynamic Universe model. Book 4 deals about prediction and finding of Blue shifted Galaxies in the universe

With axioms like... No Isotropy; No Homogeneity; No Space-time continuum; Non-uniform density of matter(Universe is lumpy); No singularities; No collisions between bodies; No Blackholes; No warm holes; No Bigbang; No repulsion between distant Galaxies; Non-empty Universe; No imaginary or negative time axis; No imaginary X, Y, Z axes; No differential and Integral Equations mathematically; No General Relativity and Model does not reduce to General Relativity on any condition; No Creation of matter like Bigbang or steady-state models; No many mini Bigbangs; No Missing Mass; No Dark matter; No Dark energy; No Bigbang generated CMB detected; No Multi-verses etc.

Many predictions of Dynamic Universe Model came true, like Blue shifted Galaxies and no dark matter. Dynamic Universe Model gave many results otherwise difficult to explain

Additionally you may please have a look at the CONCLUSION of the essay.

For me character count came as problem

I will revise the essay in near future and upload it to viXra ASAP

............... Your words..........

.........................

Early in my career I learned to be cautious about interpreting the results of simulations. Would the results of your simulations change if you allowed for black holes?

..............Reply...................

This is not a General relativity type solution. Solves many problems which GR can not solve.

Dynamic Universe model is a mathematical frame work that can be applied to different sets of masses. It is an General N-body problem solution with out singularities.

In the simulations of Dynamic Universe Model, I will have to give the value of masses in Kg and their distances in Cartesian XYZ co-ordinates in meters, Many times I take the origin (0,0,0) as Center of Sun; But it can be center of earth, or center of Galaxy or center of molecule which depends on the problem.

Black holes I can not give, as it is infinite density. If there is an error of Blackhole, the COMPUTER stops as it gets "1/0" one divided by zero error. It never occurred except in the cases, when same set of coordinates for some mass.

............... Your thank for your kind words William Goodwin,

I hope you also will work-out some other new problem using Dynamic Universe Model. It may take few day to few months, depending on the problem.

I am repeating my reply here for your easy perusal please....

Best Regards

=snp.

William,

A nice overview essay, and very readable. You make an important point;

"there are no consequences to the imagination in the information dimension; whereas in the physical world there are real consequences which I identify in mine as the basis of 'feedback loops' for decisions and thus 'aims'. I suggest we first 'imagine' scenario's and get the internal biochem releases etc from imagined outcomes, so directing the actual decisions with REAL consequences!

I noticed in checking through those I hadn't read you had inadequate scores to qualify (10) so I'll get you one closer (and a bit higher!) before the impending deadline.

I hope you may get a chance to read, score and comment on mine.

Very best

Peter