Dear Dr. Alyssa Adams,

Thank you for your kind feedback!

I am in agreements. While in the essay I did not reflect on the ontological status of mathematics, merely that we cannot reason scientifically without the usage of mathematics, I believe that math while deeply linked to our psychology is at the same time independent of it.

Alien species aside, we can also readily use computers to do mathematics, and I think that is a good argument that mathematics indeed is independent of the human mind.

An interesting experiment is to ask complete novices in computer science and mathematics to code some basic arithmetic. For instance, raising a number by an exponent. Many people don't know that any number raised to zero is one, and indeed would be surprised that their correct code automatically gives the right response. If mathematics was purely psychological, then there was no way they could have given a code that produced a counter-intuitive but correct ans. Or at least this is how I would interpret this situation.

Again, thanks for your feedback here!

Best Wishes,

Raiyan Reza

Dear Syed Raiyan Nuri Reza,

Thank you for rating my essay, I am giving my reply to your post there.

I rated you well today, it is the 8 th rating, not to be confused...

Best wishes

=snp

Dear Syed Raiyan Nuri Reza,

Thank you for your reply and reading my essay. You are correct about electrical engineering.

I posted a reply on my essay to your comments. Hope you will have a look...

Best Regards

=snp

    Dear Professor Satyavarapu Naga Parameswara Gupta,

    Thanks!

    Read your feedback, and have produced a reply!

    Best Wishes,

    Raiyan Reza

    Dear Professor Satyavarapu Naga Parameswara Gupta ,

    I am sorry for missing out on this thread!

    And, thanks for your remarks on my future potential. and for your good rating!

    Best Wishes,

    Raiyan Reza

    Dear Syed Raiyan Nuri Reza

    Thank you for studying my essay, I request you rate it also....

    See my reply to you on my post....

    Best wishes to your essay

    =snp

    Dear Raiyan Reza,

    Thank you for your recent post on my essay

    Thank you for doing such favor, I request you to go through my Blog

    " https://vaksdynamicuniversemodel.blogspot.com/ " to study further on some cosmological questions.

    Best Wishes to your essy

    =snp

      Dear Professor Satyavarapu Naga Parameswara Gupta,

      Sure, I will keep an eye out on your blog.

      Thanks for your comments here!

      Best Wishes,

      Raiyan Reza

      Dear Raiyan Reza,

      I have discovered a simple mathematical structure that seems to generate our universe in about the same time as Tegmark's MUH, the system indicates that there is only one level, our reality. I think the system sheds a clear answer to your thesis. It is verifiable with simple modifiable JavaScript programs. Thanks

        Dear Raiyan and Rastin,

        I enjoyed very much your essay, I find myself in almost complete agreement with it. And it's very well written and argued. I like the discussion whether Nature is monolingual or bi/poly-lingual, and you already know of course that we share the view that most of our thoughts about the world are our own projections, as you well said anything else attributed to her are fictitious ramblings or vague contemplations of the human mind which has no bearing on what Nature is and is not. You already noticed our points of agreement, I would mention another one, concerning Tegmark's proposed the limitation of MUH to the computable structures. I wish you the best in this essay contest!

        Cheers,

        Cristi

          Dear Cristi,

          Thank you for taking time in reading my work, your positive feedback and leaving behind a comment here!

          I am glad that indeed upon reading our work you find mutual grounds with your presentation, research and reasoning; which coming from a researcher to an undergrad like us is vindication!

          Thanks a lot for engaging in conversation, and it was once again, a delight discovering and reading your work!

          Best Wishes,

          Raiyan and Rastin

          Dear Professor Adel Sadeq,

          Thanks for leaving a comment here!

          I will read your work!

          Best Wishes,

          Raiyan