Lorraine Ford
Whether one agrees with Sean Carroll’s defence of the “Many-Worlds Interpretation” or not, it is clear that the mathematical symbols of physics don’t and can’t represent the elaborate behind-the-scenes goings-on that are supposed to happen with the “Many-Worlds Interpretation”.
These elaborate, hidden, behind-the-scenes goings-on can, in part, be represented algorithmically, although the assumption of entire new worlds can’t be represented algorithmically.
………………….
But leaving aside the “Many-Worlds Interpretation”, even the ordinary mathematical symbols of both physics and mathematics, symbols which actually, pretty much, only represent relationships between categories, assume that hidden behind-the-scenes activities are going on.
I’m saying that the hidden behind-the-scenes activities of mathematics, including the mathematics of the real-world moving mathematical system are:
- Something (“matter”, i.e. small parts of the universe) knows/ is conscious of the mathematical situations, in terms of all the categories, relationships, and numbers that are simultaneously TRUE from a point of view within the mathematical system.
- Something (“matter”, i.e. small parts of the universe) moves the mathematical situations (i.e. freely jumps the numbers that apply to its own categories) in response to this knowledge of the mathematical situations, whereby other numbers that apply to other categories in the relationships/ equations also jump because of the mathematical relationships.
I’m saying that, as opposed to assuming that mathematics is a self-sufficient self-powered “black box”, 1 and 2 above are necessary aspects of mathematics, including the mathematics of the real-world moving mathematical system.
I’m saying that Sean Carroll’s (and other people’s) “black boxing”, which discounts the necessary, behind-the-scenes non-deterministic activities of mathematics, is what allows him to (wrongfully) claim that the mathematics of the world (in terms of the categories, relationships, and numbers) points to a deterministic real-world moving system.