"Rather than viewing information as an abstract, mathematical concept, constructor theory takes it to be fundamentally physical..."

As explained here and here, that is a fundamental mistake.

Rob McEachern

a month later
  • [deleted]

Reality is the set of all things that exist:

Every set is a subset of the universal set:

A ⊆ U.

Reality is the subset as well as the powerset of itself:

R ⊆ R(S).

  • [deleted]

The above is proof that reality is naturally simulating itself.

  • [deleted]

Information is more "physical" than physical.

a month later

about information,...

Landauer's principle formulated in 1961 states that logical irreversibility implies physical irreversibility and demonstrated that information is physical.

The mass-energy-information equivalence principle featured

AIP Advances 9, 095206 (2019); https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5123794

Melvin M. Vopsona)

Pls Take account of those formulae

-ln(W) = ( action)/h = tОЅ = ( mtcВІ)/h = (k(b) T lnвЃЎ(2)t)/h = (m l(P)ВІ)/(h t(P)) = (m G)/(2ПЂcВіtP ) = (m G)/kcВі = mв€љ(G/2ПЂch)

""Mass, energy and movement of information are respectively dark matter, dark energy, and gravity.""

    to be more accurate about the previous post and formulae,....

    I=-ln(W)=( action)/h= tОЅ =( mtcВІ)/h=(k(b) T lnвЃЎ(2)t)/h=(m l(P)ВІ)/(h t(P))=(m G)/(2ПЂcВіtP )=(m G)/kcВі= mв€љ(G/2ПЂch)

    Where:

    I: information

    W, О©: number of ways the atoms or molecules of how a thermodynamic system can be arranged

    the number of arrangements that are counted by Boltzmann entropy reflects the amount of Shannon information that would be needed to implement any particular arrangement of matter and energy

    w, О© number of complexions of the system or number of configurations

    Action: E*t

    t: time

    ОЅ: frequency

    m: mass

    c: Speed of light in vacuum 299792458 mв‹...sв€'1 ((exact by definition)

    h: Planck constant defined as 6.62607015Г--10в€'34 Jв‹...s exactly)

    Kb: Boltzmann constant 1.38064 Г--10-23 J/K

    T: temperature at which the bit of information is stored

    lp: Planck length 1.616255(18)Г--10в€'35 m

    tp: Planck time 5.391247(60)Г--10в€'44 s

    G: gravitational constant 6,674 30(15) Г-- 10в€'11 m3 kgв€'1 sв€'2

    k: wavenumber as 2 ПЂ /О»

    ///

    ///

    it s about Entropic Information Theory and quantum Gravity

    information is the code and

    ""the code is what create the process but is itself too the process""

    "BIT FROM BIT"

      Hi Olivier,

      Welcome on this wonderful platform. I like your ideas, I consider too the DE and DM in my model being essential , the main informations being in this space vacuum of the DE in series finite of spheres where the space disappears due to specific volumes implyimng a superfluidity for the 3 spacetimes .

      At this moment we can just observe this GR. I have reached the quantum gravitation like this in considering the 3 systems merging under the codes and informations of this DE and so implying the baryonic ordinary matter and its fields and properties, the fact that the series finite of this DE encode the photons and the cold dark matter become interesting considering the motions, rotations oscillations of this serie if the number does not change and the volumes too don t change, that implies so that the densities and motions oscillations become relevant , and the deformations can be made with the symplectomorphisms preserving the volumes, it is the meaning of the tool that I have invencted the spherical topological geometrical algebras in fact.

      The informations so become very important considering the 3 main systems merging more this baryonic matter like result.The evolution can be better understood considering still the DE and DM still disponible at this cosmological scale. Your equation intrigues me , I have this intuitive equation in my model considering the DM and DE encoded, E=m(c^2+Xl^2)+Y , regards

      I believe Olivier that all is a question of philosophy about the origin of this universe. The actual researchs inside our theoretical community consider mainly the photons osciilating vibrating and this GR. They utilise the geometrical algebras like hopf, clifford or Lie and the strings or the geometrodynamics to explain the topologies, geometries and they create extradimensions like in the strings with 10D, 11D,26D .

      But at my opinion and it is just my opinion I am not better than the others, they are in a philosophical prison considering only these photons and strings in 1D at this planck scale oscillating connected with a 1D cosmic field of this GR. There are deep philosophical problems and our deepest unknowns cannot be found even with partitions with the numbers, categories, padics, non commutativity...it is mainly because they consider the fields like origin and they correlate so the informations with this.

      But if our actual informations are just human invenctions like for our conputing, so we turn in round in this philosophical prison. Now if the real primoridal informations are in this space vacuum and that we must converge with the others, our actual informations in our actual computing more the photons and the dark matter, so we must rank them and try to reach these main informations of the universe from this DE. It is complex, for me the real universal quantum computing is there and not with the annealings or just waves and fields and photons. But that must converge somewhere.

      ""I believe Olivier that all is a question of philosophy about the origin of this universe. The actual researchs inside our theoretical community consider mainly the photons osciilating vibrating and this GR. They utilise the geometrical algebras like hopf, clifford or Lie and the strings or the geometrodynamics to explain the topologies, geometries and they create extradimensions like in the strings with 10D, 11D,26D""

      it is not my opinion....and im not the only one... !!!

      see : https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9310026

      Since further discussion of this 4 dimensional problem becomes a bit intricate it is illustrative to remove one dimension and treat space as 2 dimensional, space-time as 3 dimensional.

      """On a Planckian scale, our world is not in 3 + 1 dimensions. On the contrary, the degrees of observable freedom can best be described as if they were defined Boolean variables on a two-dimensional network, evolving over time. This observation, deduced from nothing less than arguments of unitarity, entropy and many other arguments"""

      ""Therefore I prefer not to speculate that quantum mechanics breaks down at the Planck scale, but in stead to suspect that quantum mechanics becomes trivial there: quantum superpositions are still allowed there but become irrelevant.""

      Even though the problems just mentioned are grave and conceptually difficult to disentangle, they do not seem to be insurmountable.

      Our basic problem is that there seem to be too many symmetry requirements and the Hilbert space of physically realizable states seems to be too small.

      The picture we sketched of the 2+1 (or perhaps it is better to say 2+2) dimensional nature of our micro-universe seems to follow from quite general arguments. Rejecting any of these arguments leads to quite different and perhaps equally if not more difficult problems, and one cannot help observing that one's preferences seem to be related to nearly religeous prejudices. Besides the author not many other physicists have tried this particular avenue. We advocate its further persuit.

      The emergence of a Hilbert space with a Copenhagen interpretation of its inner products is a quite natural feature of any theory with the following characteristics at a local scale:

      the system must have discrete degrees of freedom at tiny distance scales, and the laws of evolution must be reversible in time.

      With discrete degrees of freedom one can construct Hilbert space in a quite natural way by postulating that any state of the physical degrees of freedom corresponds to an element of a basis of this Hilbert space[1].

      Reversibility in time is required if we wish to see a quantum superposition principle: the norm of all states is then preserved, even if they are quantum superpositions of these basis elements

      We conclude that one has to attribute the black hole entropy not to the space-time metric itself but to the quantized fields present there (which of course does include the small quantum fluctuations of the metric itself), and then one must choose a cut-off sufficiently close to the horizon such that it exactly matches the known black hole entropy (1).

      In short, the black hole entropy includes the entropy of the quantized fields in its neighborhood

      about origin and information .....

      The initial state is a kaotic state of informational equilibrium where the surplus of information at equilibrium is translated into order therefore energy, light and sound ....and Mass this occurs following The Meissner effect (or Meissner-Ochsenfeld effect)

      with new original model of the fundamental physical vacuum non-removable background. This non-removable informational background present at all scales of which information mass, energy and motion, are respectively dark matter, dark energy and gravity.

      (PDF) Entropic Information Theory. Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/356378350_Entropic_Information_Theory [accessed Nov 30 2021].

      2 months later
      • [deleted]

      This bears some resemblance to my statement from 2014 on these forums, reality is time symmetric.

      7 months later

      first of all, we must be agree on the definition of information used,.....

      **

      as information it is a quantum state change due to the modification of one degree of freedom of the considered quantum system...

      **

      For this quantic way to describe the information concept, we have gone further into the exploration of the notion of information viewed here as the fundamental building block of the universe, the entangled quantum information.

      By introducing, the mass-energy-information equivalence principle already enonced by Melvin Vopson into some famous equations in physics such as the Hidden thermodynamic of Louis de Broglie formula, the classical entropy formulation, the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy formula, the bekenstein bound, or even certain works of Casini, the entropic Information theory shed light on new global perspectives.

      www.entropicinformation.space.

        Hi Olivier, like you know I have read your works and I respect like I said your attempts. Philosophically we need indeed main primary informations and we must define them .We have invented the binary codes and the informations for the computing and with the boolean algebras and algorythms we evolve for this computing. If now we consider how the informations act to create this universe, it becomes complex , but we need informations for the symmetries breakings and the diversity of matters and its evolution , we must have changes in fact.

        If we consider now the actual reasonings with the general relativity and photons massless carrying the informations like if we had strings for example inside these photons at this planck scale and that this 1D comsic field of the GR carries informations, so they are inside photons massles , so they cannot have a mas. In my model it is different I consider that the main informations are in this spacxe vacuum massless of the DE , in both cases they have no mass these informations . The mass seems to need a cause , we have a missing mass to explain for our standard model even if the higgs have explained a part with the W and Z bosons and the higgs mechanisms, I beleive that the scalar fields massless and massive of the DE and the DM are these higgs mechanism and permit to give a mass, the same kind of reasoning can be considered for the missing mass and with axions from the DM encoded and with the scalar massless fields of this DE we can explain thje missing mass with these gluons and quarks. That is why the mass baryonic is mainly due to this non baryonic mass in fac and the informations them seem massless. See that if the main informations are massless in this DE and is antigravitation, that permits to balance the gravitational systems of photons and CDM encoded in this vacuum. It is the meaning of my intutitive equation about the mass energy equivalence. We need cause, if there are informations primary they seem to be in this space vacuum of this DE and it seems massless. We need to go farer than this GR and SR at my opinion. That is why the aim seems to unify the lambda CDM model with the3 QM instead to unify the GR and the QM. In all cases that permits to consider a deeper logic and that explains many things . If the universe is mainly made of partiles in this fluidity of spacetimes due to specific spherical volumes and specific series for the photons, the CDM and the DE , the motions rotations oscillations of these 3D spheres in this fluidity become interesting. If the 3 systems merge together to create the ordinary matter under the main codes of this vacuum of the DE antigravitational , that becomes relevant considering the pure motions rotations oscillations of these spheres if the volumes are preserved and the number of series also. That implies a new theory of informations in fact considering this DE possessing the main informations. They seem to have no mass simply, the mass is baryonic or not baryonic, the DM seems quanta of mass and the photons quanta of heat and electromagnetism , the universe seems simple, a kind of fifth force appears also and is antigravitational balancing the whole and seems to be not constant , the relevance is there considering the changes and broken symmetries. that is why the informations of this DE are more than fascinating epistemologically, philosophically, physically speaking.

        this dynamical energetical fluid of this DE seems the key for the main informations.....and it is like a fifth force and probably permit the encoding of photons and the CDM for our standard model , it is like an energy of negative pressure permitting to balance the gravitational 2 other systems. It is not that the works of einstein about the GR is not correlct but not complete and that we must simply relativate our observations and foundamentals causing the ordinary matter. It is like I said that newton and einstein were right in their referentials but generally and universally we need to complete this gravitation with this negative pressure of this dynamical energetical antigravitational fluid.

        ""Hi Olivier, like you know I have read your works and I respect like I said your attempts. Philosophically we need indeed main primary informations and we must define them"

        in the Superfluid vacuum theory (SVT), sometimes known as the BEC vacuum theory, is an approach in theoretical physics and quantum mechanics where the fundamental physical vacuum (non-removable background) is viewed as superfluid or as a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC). a new model for the aether according to which it is a superfluid state of fermion and anti-fermion pairs, describable by a macroscopic wave function. With small fluctuations of superfluid background obey the Lorentz symmetry, even if the superfluid itself is non-relativistic.

        The initial state is a kaotic state of informational equilibrium where the surplus of information at equilibrium is translated into order therefore energy, light and sound ....and Mass

        this occurs following The Meissner effect (or Meissner-Ochsenfeld effect)

        Hi Olivier, it is this vacuum the key for these informations I believe. Now the problem is philosophical also considering our choices for these main informations from the universe with a kind of mathematical accident or from a kind of god, an infinite eternal consciousness. After our choices considering this vacuum and the main informations depend of our philosophy also, I have chosen to consider the main informations in this vacuum of the DE , scalar massless fields , others have chosen the vacuum of this GR and after they consider points or strings connected with this vacuum and its main fields and informations. The relevance I believe humbly with this dark energy possessing the main codes is that it can solves many problems in being a fifth force for our standard model and the fact to be antigravitational permits to balance the gravitational photonic and cold dark matter systems .

        All this is not easy to affrim because we have philosophical and physical limitations but this DE like a fluid dynamical and energetical of pure informations massless antigravitational is relevant for me.

        It is mainly how we consider the informations, the energy , the mass in fact generally and we have the free will to think like we want of course, I believe strongly that this GR alone and the SR have problems and that this gravitation needs to be completed , that is why I have created this intuitive equation about the mass energy equivalence , and Y in my equation considering this DE can be correlated with the theories of informations.

        Your attemps is respectable because you try to unify the mass, the energy, the informations , me too in my model, it is just that we see differently the philosophy of origin.In all cases we need to better understanmd all this and the main informations indeed seems a key, regards

        That said Olivier the information black hole paradox has been an interesting work. The aim was to link the general relativity and the quantum mechanic mainly. The works of Hwking and Bekenstein have been interesting about the fact that we have these radiations. The BHs have an electric charge, a mass, an angular momentum, and in the process of evaporation they have considered these informations.

        So I see your idea for the link betweem quantum gravitation, information and mass and energy. We arrive at the real problem about the gravitation. If you consider the lost of informations or the collapses of the waves functions, it is there that we arrive at these philosophical questions about the origin of the universe and if you consider only the GR like cause of this reality, we have problems not renormalisable and unknowns not explained because it is mainly how we consider this origin and main causes of this QM and so how we consider the informations and the gravitation.

        If you consider these radiations and the evaporation and the planck scale with the informations, so we arrive at how is stored and encoded an information but we don t know really and like I said the problem is philosophical about what is a primary information and its origin. Wwe dont even know if the siingularitiesw exist and many confusions appear in these reasonings about the storing of these informations and the link with this time even considering the past and future.

        That is why the problem is philosophical and how we interpret this GR and the philosophy of origin, if you take the time evolution and the GR , so you intepretat the causalities and localities in function of the philosophy chosen, and that implies specific chosen referentials and so personal intepretations of this gravitation and these informations.If you extend the co ncepts of Gibbs and von neuman entropy , there still it is a ^philosophical choice about the zero entropy and how you consider the evaporation of the BHs and so the informations.

        That implies that the informations paradox is just a paradox if you consider the actual limited reasonings of this GR and if you consider only the gravitation of this GR without thinking beyond the box of this GR.It is mainly how you approach the gravitation and the informations and how you consider even this quantum gravitation which is for me a pure newtonian mechanic between massive particles of this standard model and not from this GR with gravitons being the quanta of gravitational waves.

        If the informations are not in this reasoning and are not lost in the reasonings of these evaporations of BHs, so the degree of freedom and the violations of the energy momentum conservations and localities are not the key .

        The massless and massive particles so become inmportant philosophically about how we approcach the informations and the philosophy of origin of the universe, if you consider the gravitons and the photons massless for example and that you consider the loss of informations in function of energies, it is just a personal choice about this said philosophy of origin of informations, and the bekenstien bound will not change the fact that we have probably deeper parameters to add to this puzzle about the mass, the energy and the informations primary .

        Hey @steve

        ""Hi Olivier, it is this vacuum the key for these informations I believe. ""

        "Essentially, entanglement holds space together. It's the glue that makes the different pieces of space hook up with one another" John Preskill

        ""Quantum entanglement as geometric glue,the geometry entanglement relationship have come from condensed-matter physics and quantum information theory: fields in which entanglement already plays a central part. "" is the essence of Van Raamsdonk's paper

        We are on opposite side so !!!

        but on that:"In all cases we need to better understanmd all this and the main informations indeed seems a key, regards" we are agree

        ""Your attemps is respectable because you try to unify the mass, the energy, the informations""

        thx, indeed,the black holes entropic Information formula can calculate the entangled Hawking radiation down to the quantum system, describing black hole independently of the area law of the entropy of Bekenstein-Hawking. The black holes entropic information formula is equal to the universal bound originally found by Jacob Bekenstein. Which is equal by Casini's work to the difference between the expectation value of the modular Hamiltonian in the excited state and the vacuum state, itself equal to the Von Neumann entropy. The ultraviolet divergences can be avoided by taking differences between quantities computed in an excited state and the same quantities computed in the vacuum state; this must be put in relation to Ryu and Takayanagi conjecture, a general formula for the fine-grained entropy of quantum systems coupled to gravity

        The Entangled Informational Universe.

        .

        .

        ""DE like a fluid dynamical and energetical of pure informations massless antigravitational is relevant for me.""

        Landauer's principle formulated in 1961 states that logical irreversibility implies physical irreversibility and demonstrated that information is physical. Here we formulate a new principle of mass-energy-information equivalence proposing that a bit of information is not just physical, as already demonstrated, but it has a finite and quantifiable mass while it stores information.

        IS NOT for me.....

        The deep unknowns , the philosophy of origin, the energy, the mass, the informations must be considered in a model at my hum ble opinion, if not it is not really innovative and it is limited. Yours works is from Vopson , and after you have taken the works of Hawking, Bekenstein von neuman mainly and you conclude an equation in taking their works in changing small things, it seems not sufficient generally . Like I said you could develop your model in philosophy and in correlating with the foundamental works of the GR and QFT and QM, for example the minkowski spacetime, the yang mills theory ....and the geometrical algebras also of lie and clifford in trying to consider unifications of the GR and QM if it is your choice to consider only the photons and this GR like primary essence.You must develop in fact . The informations are dynamical indeed and physical and need a cause but withjout a definition of these informations , a cause philosophical and dynamical,that does not act . The problem is there you don t develop the origin philosophical and physical of these informations, I have given you an idea, god or mathematical accident , you need to have a cause, if the dark photon and photons are considered like the binary codes , it could be interesting inj playing twith ntheir fields and oscillations and the mass energy equivalence of einstein but you don t want to develop apparently, we don t know what is your inmformations philosophically and physically, I don t know me, try to correlate with the fields and the waves and the extradiemnsions maybe but link with the QFT, the GR, the philosophy ......make general links for these informations, there it is not sufficient generally

        hey @steve

        ""Yours works is from Vopson , and after you have taken the works of Hawking, Bekenstein von neuman mainly and you conclude an equation ""

        Indeed, in Entropic inforamation theory, We start from the hidden thermodynamic of Louis De Broglie, where we replace the mass by the mass of bit of information [4]. After we used this mass of bit of information at the Hawking temperature in the framework of the black hole thermodynamics and in the perspective of the Hawking radiation, the process of evaporation of the black hole, we will compare some black hole data from all over the black holes scale to confirm that the black holes entropic information formula equal to the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy, but, also equal to the Bekenstein bound. Results are put in relation to the work of Casini from 2008 about Bekenstein and Von Neumann entropy, about the fine-grained entropy and the coarse grained entropy. After this we will put in relation the black holes entropic information to the Ryu-Takayanagi formula which is a general formula for the fine-grained entropy of gravity-coupled quantum systems.

        ""Like I said you could develop your model in philosophy and in correlating with the foundamental works of the GR and QFT and QM, for example the minkowski spacetime""

        The new entropic information approach take in consideration the Quantum field theory in curved spacetime (QFTCS)

        The black holes entropic Information formula can calculate the entangled Hawking radiation down to the quantum system, describing black hole independently of the area law of the entropy of Bekenstein-Hawking. The black holes entropic information formula is equal to the universal bound originally found by Jacob Bekenstein. Which is equal by Casini's work to the difference between the expectation value of the modular Hamiltonian in the excited state and the vacuum state, itself equal to the Von Neumann entropy. The ultraviolet divergences can be avoided by taking differences between quantities computed in an excited state and the same quantities computed in the vacuum state; this must be put in relation to Ryu and Takayanagi conjecture, a general formula for the fine-grained entropy of quantum systems coupled to gravity

        The Entangled Informational Universe