The problem with string theory, quantum loop gravity and all these other mathematically fancy ideas is that they don't actually behave like spacetime, the big bang or modern physics. Instead of moving science forward, these theories are painting us into a corner; worse still, there is no experiment that can prove or disprove these theories. At least with my expanding graviton theory, they actually act like established physics AND there is an experiment that can prove it.

    Time dilation is the hint that time is tied directly to the speed of light. The smartest people in the physics community are working on string theory and loop gravity. But neither of those physics theories has ever stopped to consider the conundrum that the speed of light is invariant for all observers. That is why progress in physics is slowing down like a steam powered train that has run out of coal.

    I get ignored because the physics community thinks that the laws of physics are made of string theory (wiggling spaghetti) or quantum loops (wiggling rubber bands). But I am arguing that spacetime is made of gravitons that expand from a point, at the speed of light. That gravitons have a geometry that is roughly spherical with volume V = 4/3 piR^3, where R = ct. I don't have to assume the existence of 11 dimensions, I have a graviton that creates spacetime itself. But what do I know? I'm just looking at quantum mechanics, general relativity and the big bang to figure out what they all have in common. What do I know?

      You seem to be demonstrating loose association. Putting ideas together which have little if anything to do with each other. Saying a gravitation becomes space-time or a wave-function does not "cut the mustard".

      I would say that you are overlooking the very clues that would lead us to a breakthrough in technology. But just remember, time dilation and length contraction occur because the speed of light is invariant. Something about the mechanisms that evolve time and procedure the dimensional quality of nature is tied to the speed of light. That's the clue.

      Hi Georgina,

      "You seem to be demonstrating loose association. Putting ideas together which have little if anything to do with each other. Saying a gravitation becomes space-time or a wave-function does not "cut the mustard". "

      The physics community has been trying to figure out how quantum mechanics and gravity are unified. But when I offer an answer, you say I'm making loose associations. In truth, my idea about the graviton is based upon established physics. Do you remember the derivation of special relativity? The speed of light is invariant for all inertial reference frames. it's the same for the frame of the train (in Einstein's thought experiment) and is invariant for the train station as well. The geometry of both reference frames is tied to the speed of light in such a way that there are length contraction and time dilation effects. If my expanding graviton idea is right, then both the train and the train station are emitting expanding gravitons. Gravitons can have a velocity with respect to other gravitons, but since the gravitons are acting as both the measuring stick and the clock, then the speed of light expansion of the gravitons becomes the dominating effect. Gravitons expand at the speed of light and eventually fill all space. Superstrings and quantum loops do not fill all space. That is why I think that my expanding graviton idea is a better fit to the laws of physics than superstrings and quantum loops.

      Since wave functions are solutions to ALL quantum mechanics systems, and there are momentum and position quantum states for ALL wave functions, then maybe it is just the case that ALL wave functions are just collections of momentum and position quantum states. My idea of unification of QM and GR is to say that gravitons expand at the speed of light UNLESS they are captured by charges and become a wave function. If that were the case, then gravitons are just collections of position and momentum quantum states. They can expand, overlap and become spacetime OR they can be captured by charges to become wave functions.

      Another cool thing about my graviton idea is that it doesn't take an Antony Lisi or an Albert Einstein to figure out that if gravitons are behaving like wave functions AND spacetime, then gravitons are probably also behaving like quantum entanglements. You could literally use a laser and a crystal to entangle photons. Entangled photons have quantum states for position and momentum. You could use fiber optics and centrifugres to align those quantum states into a way to store gravitational potential energy.

      The advantage of my idea over superstring theory and quantum loop gravity is that superstrings and quantum loops cannot be isolated and experimented on.

      Cheers,

      Jason Wolfe

      The speed of light is both a clock and a ruler. Speed of light c= wavelength (ruler) * frequency (clock). If gravitons expand at the speed of light, then they tell time and measure distance. Time is actually made of a near infinite number of gravitons that tell time.

      Could it be otherwise?4

      Many years ago, I learned a difficult truth to practice. I learned that results matter more than hard work. I have no doubt that creating mathematics for string theory and quantum loop gravity is hard work. But if it's wrong, then the benefits will be missing ( like they are now).

      In contrast, if a theory is right, like my expanding graviton theory, then there will be great benefits. The theory will make sense, and there will be an experiment that can test it.

        A graviton is very well-defined in string theory. In fact one of the great virtues of string theory is that you can't get rid of gravitons!

        Meanwhile, "The metre is defined as the length of the path travelled by light in a vacuum in 1/299 792 458 of a second."

        They are not looking back in time but receiving signals that have arrived at their locations. Products are made from the signals which exist in an observer of them's present.

        I am arguing that a graviton begins its existences at a point, and expands at the speed of light in a spherical pattern (much like the big bang) until either it is captured by particles to become the thing that wave functions are describing, or it expands to many light seconds in diameter, overlaps with other gravitons, and becomes part of the spacetime continuum.

        The problem I have with string theory is that superstrings, as near as I can tell, are just tiny pieces of spaghetti that wiggle around, but don't act like spacetime. Am I missing something?

        Satellites and observatories can look at light and see events that happened billions of years ago.

        They are equipment, they don't really look and see. Observation products are made from the signals received and astronomers or cosmologists make calculations and judgments about what the source objects were and how far away the source objects were,when the 'light' was emitted.

        It's about the only thing cosmologists can do, given their level of ambition.

        The nature of time is related to timespace being precursive to the nature of space as spacetime.

        The dividing 'spacetime mirror' for this is described by M-theory in 11 dimensions forming a boundary for 12-dimensional self-relative Vafa-brane theory on a undefined outside with a defined 10-dimensional string theory on the self-relative inside.

        The self-relativity refers to Möbian-Klein connectivity of self-dual onesided surfaces; which in convolution cancel the positive curvature of de Sitter spacetime with the negarive curvature of Anti de Sitter spacetime.

        More simply the Quantum Big Bang Singularity (QBBS) becomes defined in Dirac's magnetic monopole at the initial boundary between timespace and spacetime. The Dirac string then conifolds from potential infinity space in well defined initial boundary conditions algorithmically defined from the timespace defining the Planck epoch preceding the QBBS.

        Dirac's monopole as the generator for spacetime in the QBBS then manifests as the classical electron and enabling the latter to exchange its point-particular nature in Quantum Field Theory (QFT) and Quantum Electrodynamics (QED) with that of the monopole sigularity.

        Details can be found in the attached pdf.

        https://vixra.org/abs/2007.0073

        https://cosmosdawn.net/forum/threads/the-birth-of-god-as-a-superbrane-and-the-creation-of-the-universe.8801/

        Jason; you are 'missing' the Dirac string.

        This prior realm or world is described as the outside boundary of the manifested singularity of the QBBS, with the inside boundary defining physical universe as the fifth of five abstract mathematical singularities and as a one-dimensional entity in transforming its nature as a mathematical point into that of a mathematical line known as a Dirac string. A Dirac string so allows the mathematical abstraction of the point space to transform into a point line requiring space to extend into as itself and as a Y direction in some coordinate system.

        The minimum parameter spacetime so enables a 2nd dimension to emerge from the Dirac string, as the 1st dimension of a minimized line segment of wavelength Lweyl curls itself around the mathematical point space it used to occupy as a segment of the Dirac string. This process changes the 1st dimension of the Dirac string from a time dimension into a 1st space dimension as the now space limited summation of mathematical line segments and redefines the newly created space dimension of the XY-plane as a quasi-time dimension.

        The entire Dirac string so transforms itself as a mathematical point without extent into a mathematical line of any number of such point spaces to create the Dirac string extending in two polar directions from the mathematical singularity of the QBBS. As there is no limit of how many mathematical point can exist in the Information-Energy prior spacetime plenum, the Dirac string is initially infinite as a consequence of no spacetime existing at the point of creation known as the first instant of time or the Instanton.

        As the individual point spaces integrate as a sum of such point spaces however, each individual point preserved its individual universal identity in circularizing its point space into a membrane- or string space in the XY-plane. The Weyl wavelength Lweyl so became redefined from its circular form as the perimeter of a point circle as the displacement of the circumference from the center of the point circle as its wormhole radius. With the creation of a 2nd area or surface dimension from the point circle count from the mathematical point count, two orthogonal directions emerged from the potential infinite Dirac string, which became upper and lower bounded in changing the expansion from the lower bounded origin to the universal north as self-relative positive upper bound in a direction from the origin towards the self-relative positive east with a simultaneous creation of the self-relative negative west direction in the transformation of the expansion towards the self-relative south as the mirror of the positive and negative polarities of the upper bound in the origin.

        This creation of the 2nd dimension so formed a limit for the mathematical point spaces extending in space and in time into two opposite directions. The potential infinite linespace became halted in the QBBS defining the two endpoints as two Weylian wormholes defined in the Guth-de Broglie Inflaton and mirrored at the origin as two polar opposite but identical minimum timespace configurations. The northern positively charged wormhole so observes the self-relative anticlockwise rotation as effect of the righthanded torque of the Dirac string projecting orthogonally from the newly created XY-plane into the XZ-plane of a so created 3rd dimension and with the torque angular displacement defining a new positively charged part of the northern hemisphere as pointing into the positive Z-axis direction or 'out' from the XY-plane. The southern negatively charged wormhole in the southern hemisphere corollary projects the torque in the negatively charged XY-plane in a clockwise rotation 'into' the XY-plane of the 3rd dimension to complete the 8 sectors of the geometrically defined encompassing 3-dimensional sphere with radius twice the torus radius. The four torus radii so define the radius of the sphere in meeting at the QBBS singularity physically defined as the Dirac magnetic monopole. The 2nd quasi-time dimension so becomes a real space dimension and the newly created 3rd dimension takes its place as a quasi-time dimension acting on the XY-plane as a flatland of membrane spacetime.

        https://cosmosdawn.net/forum/threads/the-birth-of-god-as-a-superbrane-and-the-creation-of-the-universe.8801/

        For some reason to upload appropriate pdf's is disallowed.

        Hi Tony,

        Forgive my impatience, but in my opinion, the physics community is focused on endlessly complicated mathematics that doesn't actually lead to an experiment or any new technology.

        In contrast, my very simple idea that a graviton exists, actually does lead to an experiment. I think that the graviton will expand from a point, at the speed of light (to make the derivation of special relativity true). I also think that the graviton is actually filled with quantum states for momentum and position. I mean, think about it: The wave function calculation of and are supposed to predict the position and momentum of where a particle is going to be. That is equivalent to saying that the position and momentum quantum states are possible places that a particle can be located and also what its momentum might be. Well those would be necessary properties of space itself and spacetime.

        A quantum entanglement between two photons would be a captured graviton. A graviton has quantum states. If a graviton is really the wave function, then there are quantum states in that graviton that can be effected by centrifuging the quantum entangled photons. If you put an optical fiber along the radius of a centrifuge, spin that centrifuge, you can simulate the conditions of a gravity field. When the photons are passed along the optical fiber, they will be redshifted or blueshifted. If there is an entanglement between them, then the entanglement will become "charged" with a gravitational potential energy.

        Tony,

        Do Dirac strings explain why the speed of light is invariant for all observers? Do they behave like the big bang (expansion of the universe from a point)? Do they explain what spacetime is really made of? My argument is that gravitons are made of quantum states which are places to put particles. Because the speed of light is built into the graviton, things like distance and progression of time are built into the graviton as c = wavelength * frequency.

        Can the Diract string do that?